ART QUILTS and JUDGING
© Joyce Hyam
Ozquilt Network Newsletter Issue #39 March 2001
In my experience, the term art quilts confuses some quilters and judges. To
clarify this, I compare the traditional artist with the contemporary one. That
is, the traditional photographic-realist artist is one with which the majority
of viewers feel comfortable and who doesn't make them feel insecure, since it
affords the pleasure of identifying with earlier visual experience. Similarly,
traditional patchworkers feel less secure with creative works.
'How to' patchwork publications are, I submit, similar to the
filling in the dots approach to drawing and children's colouring-in books, that
are so detrimental to early creativity. Once the techniques of quilting are
mastered, the next stage of venturing into artistic creativity is to get
acquainted with the elements of art, i.e. line, tone, colour, texture, and, very
importantly, feeling. To approach this stage, look at works by artists such as
Mondrian, Hundertwasser, and Gustav Klimt.
If it is the principal aim of quilters to have a perfect join
and a perfect stitch, this is commendable, but it offers no aesthetic challenge,
nor is it inventive. You can't feel very excited or creative, and it does not
offer the viewer a new experience. It is a sad indictment of judges who have to
abide by a list of points that reveal a sorry lack of truly aesthetic values. In
the last competition I entered, it was clear that the judges were at a loss
because there were no ticks in any areas of my sheet against the best features,
nor in the areas which need improvement.
It may be of interest to quote a statement I wrote about one
of my recent works. "I endeavour to give the viewer a new visual experience. My
inspiration comes from sketches in my sketch-book and from browsing through art
books. My quilting is mostly close, free stitching, using gold metallic threads.
I aim to produce works that sing and glow, made possible by the limitless range
of exotic fabrics and threads." Art quilts, then, have art in them - they are
not just ordinary quilts, a minor variation of what has been seen and done
before.
© Joyce Hyam 2001